First, make sure your visitors are real, local and looking for what you sell, and that your tracking counts calls and form fills. Then look at your site on a phone: a tap-to-call number, a fast page, a clear message, reasons to trust you and a short form. Last, check how fast someone answers. The problem is almost always in one of those spots.
1. Check that the visitors are the right visitors
More visitors only matter if they could become customers. Readers from across the country, visitors from outside your area, or fake visits from automated programs (bots) can all pump up the numbers without bringing one real customer.
- Google Search Console is a free Google tool that shows which searches bring people to your site. Open its Performance report. It lists the searches your site showed up for, how many people clicked, how often you were shown, the share who clicked and your average spot on the page (Search Console Help). Would these people hire you?
- Google Analytics is a free tool that shows who visits your site. Look at where your visitors are and which page they arrive on first. A jump in visitors from out of state, or to an old article, is a clue.
- If you run Google Ads, look at the search terms report. Google says it shows the actual searches people typed before seeing your ad. It suggests adding the ones that don’t fit as “negative keywords,” words that tell Google not to show your ad for those searches (Google Ads Help).
2. Make sure tracking isn’t the problem
Sometimes the calls are coming in and nobody is counting them. Or the form goes to an old inbox. Before you redo anything, test the basics yourself:
- Fill out your own form. Did it arrive? Where?
- Tap the phone number on your phone. Does it call the right line?
- In Google Analytics, are form fills and phone taps marked as “key events”? Google describes a key event as an action that’s especially important to your business (Google Analytics Help).
- If you run ads, are calls being counted? Google Ads can count calls from your website as a win when they last longer than a minimum length you choose (Google Ads Help).
Also ask whoever answers the phone how new callers found you. It often shows the website is doing more than the reports say.
3. Make calling easy on a phone
For most local service businesses, people ready to call are on their phones. Open your site on yours. Can you see the number without scrolling? Can you tap it to call, or is it just a picture or plain text? Is there a call button that stays on screen as you scroll? Does a pop-up cover the page?
If you do one thing after reading this, put a tap-to-call phone number at the top of every page, plus a clear button to request service.
4. Check how fast your pages load
A slow page tests people’s patience. Google has published targets for what “fast enough” means, in its web.dev guidance:
- The main part of the page should show up within 2.5 seconds.
- When someone taps a button, the page should react within 200 milliseconds (a fifth of a second).
- Things on the page shouldn’t jump around as it loads. Google scores this, and the target is 0.1 or less.
Google checks these on phones and computers, and wants at least 3 out of 4 visits to hit the targets.
Google says it uses these speed checks (it calls them Core Web Vitals) when deciding what to show in search. But good scores don’t guarantee a top spot, and chasing a perfect score may not be worth your time (Google Search Central).
Treat speed as a customer problem first. The usual culprits are huge photos, too many add-ons and heavy chat or review boxes. Our guide on how fast a website should load goes deeper.
5. Be clear, and give people reasons to trust you
Say what you do, where, and what to do next
Within a few seconds, a visitor should know what you do, where you do it and what to do next. Lots of sites open with a stock photo and a slogan like “Quality you can trust.” That says nothing. Instead, try:
- A headline that names the service and the area: “Furnace repair in Grand Rapids, same-day when available.”
- One main next step: call, or ask for a quote.
- A short line on what makes you different, said plainly and only if it’s true: licensed, family-owned, weekend hours, free estimates.
If someone searched for, or clicked an ad for, one specific service, they should arrive on the page for that service. Not your home page.
Give people reasons to trust you
Someone comparing three companies wants a reason to pick one. Show real photos of your team and work, your reviews (or a link to them), licenses and insurance where they matter, and the towns you serve.
For law firms, dental offices and other professional offices, short bios of the people clients will actually meet go a long way. Skip fake-looking stock photos and reviews with no name or details.
6. Shorten your form and answer faster
Every extra box on a form is another reason to give up. Ask for a name, a phone or email, and a short note on what they need. Save the rest for the first conversation. Tell people what happens next, and when: “We reply within one business day.”
Then stick to it. Research in Harvard Business Review found most companies weren’t answering people who reached out online nearly fast enough (HBR: The Short Life of Online Sales Leads). If calls go to voicemail during busy hours, or forms sit until the weekend, the website isn’t the problem. Our post on automatic follow-up covers simple ways to fix that.
What share of visitors should turn into calls?
Marketers call this your conversion rate. Honestly, it depends on your industry, where visitors come from, what you count and how ready they are to buy. An emergency drain cleaning page will do very differently from a blog post about kitchen remodel ideas.
For one point of comparison: WordStream’s 2025 report on Google Ads looked at 16,446 U.S. Google search ad campaigns from April 2024 through March 2025. It found the typical (median) share of ad clicks that turned into a call, form or other action was 7.52%. By industry, it was 7.33% for home and home improvement, 5.09% for attorneys and legal services, and 9.08% for dentists and dental services (WordStream 2025 Google Ads benchmarks).
Those numbers only cover people who clicked a Google ad, who are usually ready to buy. So they’re not a fair comparison for all your visitors. Your own numbers, month over month, are the best measuring stick.
Made-up example: a dental office in Detroit
Say a dental office gets more visitors after posting helpful articles, but new-patient calls stay flat. Search Console shows most of the new visitors are outside Michigan, reading a post about sensitive teeth. Meanwhile, the “new patients” page loads slowly on phones, and the phone number is buried at the very bottom. The growth in visitors is real, but it isn’t local. And the page that should turn local visitors into patients has easy fixes.
When to get help
Checked all this and still can’t tell where people give up? Our website breakdown walks through this in more detail. Our website improvement work tests changes against real calls and form fills. Ask for a free consultation if you’d like us to take a look.
Sources: Search Console Help: Performance report, Google Ads Help: Search terms report, Google Analytics Help: Key events, Google Ads Help: Website call conversions, web.dev: Web Vitals, Google Search Central: Page experience, Harvard Business Review: The Short Life of Online Sales Leads, WordStream: 2025 Google Ads benchmarks.
Related: How fast should a website load?, Getting bad leads from ads, Web design.




