Skip to content
// BLOG · PUBLISHED OCT 17, 2026

What Should a Marketing Audit Actually Check?

Your website is up and your ads are running. That doesn't mean they're bringing in work. Here's how to find out.

The Detcord GOAT finding five leaks in a glowing pipeline with a flashlight

Quick answer: A good marketing audit checks five things: whether you answer calls and messages fast, where website visitors give up, whether your business info matches everywhere, whether you can tie new customers back to where they came from, and whether people can find you on Google and in AI search. A basic audit only checks that things are turned on.

Why a basic audit isn't enough

Most audits are a checklist. Is the website online? Does it work on a phone? Are the ads running? Did you post on Facebook this month? You get a row of green checkmarks and a report that says you're in good shape.

The problem is that a checklist only tells you your marketing is turned on. It doesn't tell you if it's bringing in customers. A business can pass every check and still lose jobs every week.

A useful audit asks a different question: where do customers come from, and where do they slip away? Below are the five places we see it happen most.

1. Are you missing calls and messages?

Your marketing worked. Someone found you and called. But you were on a job, with a customer, or closed for the night, and the call went to voicemail.

Many people won't leave a message. They just call the next business on the list. Speed matters for online requests too. Research published in Harvard Business Review found that most companies don't reply to web inquiries nearly fast enough (HBR).

What to check:

  • How many calls go unanswered each week, especially after hours
  • How long it takes to reply to website forms and Facebook messages
  • Whether people get an automatic text back when you can't pick up

Our post on automating your follow-up shows simple ways to fix this.

2. Where do website visitors give up?

Lots of visitors feels good. But visitors who leave without calling don't pay the bills.

People usually leave for simple reasons. They can't find your phone number. The contact form asks too many questions. The page loads slowly on a phone. Or there's no clear next step, so they hit the back button.

What to check: walk the path a real customer takes. Search for your service, click through to your site, and try to contact yourself on your phone. Note every spot where you'd get annoyed and quit.

We cover this step by step in Website Getting Visitors but No Calls?

3. Does your business say the same thing everywhere?

Your website says you've been in business 15 years. Your Google listing says 10. Your Facebook page still has your old phone number.

Small mix-ups like these make a business look careless, and customers notice. They can also confuse Google about basic facts, like your hours or where you work.

What to check: look at your business name, phone number, address or service area, hours and list of services on your website, Google Business Profile (your free listing on Google Search and Maps), Facebook, Instagram and Yelp. They should all match. Our Google Business Profile checklist is a good place to start.

4. Are you counting customers or just likes?

Likes, followers and clicks look nice in a report. But they don't tell you if your marketing pays for itself.

These four questions matter more:

  1. How many calls and form requests came in this month?
  2. Where did each one come from: Google, Facebook, a referral, your truck?
  3. How many turned into paying jobs?
  4. How much did you spend to get each new customer?

If you can't answer them, you're guessing. The fix is usually simple: set up a way to count calls and forms, and ask every new customer how they found you. Our guide to whether your marketing pays off and our Lead Value Calculator can help.

5. Can people find you when they search?

A website can be live and still be hard to find. When someone nearby searches for what you do, you want to show up on Google Maps, not somewhere on page two.

More people are also asking AI tools like ChatGPT, or the AI answers at the top of Google, for recommendations. These tools pull from your website, your Google listing, your reviews and what other sites say about you. If that information is thin or out of date, they may suggest someone else.

What to check: search for your main services plus your town, on a phone, and see where you land. Then ask an AI tool for the best business like yours nearby. For fixes, read How to Show Up on Google Maps and how to show up in AI search.

Try this 10-minute check on your phone

You don't need any special tools. Every "no" is a spot where you may be losing customers.

  • Call your business after closing time. Does the caller get a text back, or just voicemail?
  • Search for your service plus your town. Do you show up in the top three on the map?
  • Open your website on your phone. Can you find and tap your phone number in a few seconds?
  • Fill out your own contact form. Did anyone reply within an hour?
  • Check your phone number and hours on your website, Google and Facebook. Do they match?
  • Ask ChatGPT for the best business like yours near you. Are you mentioned?
  • Think about last month's new customers. Do you know how each one found you?

Three or more "no" answers means there's probably work slipping through the cracks.

A made-up example: a plumber in Oakland County

Say a plumbing company pays for Google Ads, posts on Facebook twice a week and has a nice website. On paper, everything looks fine. But calls are down.

A real audit finds three problems. After-hours calls go to a full voicemail box. The website's phone number is only at the very bottom of the page. And the Google listing still shows hours from two years ago. None of these cost much to fix, and none would show up on a basic checklist.

When to get help

If you've worked through this list and still can't tell where customers are slipping away, a second set of eyes helps. We'll look at your whole setup and explain what we find in plain English, with no jargon and no 40-page report. You get a short list of fixes, ranked by what matters most, that you can do yourself or hand to us.

Ask for a free consultation and we'll take a look.

Sources: Harvard Business Review: The Short Life of Online Sales Leads.

// 02 — QUICK ANSWERS

Common follow-up questions.

What is a marketing audit?

A review of everything you do to get customers, from your website and Google profile to your ads and how you answer the phone, to find what's working and what isn't.

How often should I do one?

Once a year is a good habit, plus any time calls drop off and you don't know why.

Can I do it myself?

Yes. The 10-minute check in this post covers the basics. A full audit goes deeper into your tracking, ads and where you show up on Google.

What's the difference between a basic audit and a real one?

A basic audit checks that things are turned on. A real one checks whether they bring in paying customers.

// FINAL CHECK — GO FOR LAUNCH

Need this implemented?

Detcord builds the marketing, software and measurement systems described here. Tell us where you are stuck; we respond within 24 hours.

Start a conversation
// HOLIDAY DEALS

Get holiday deals by email

Detcord Digital and Faye by Detcord holiday offers, straight to your inbox. We send a confirmation email first.

Light the Fuse